'Cattle Class' And 'Holy Cows'
Any thing Wrong or Every thing Wrong?
Shashi Tharoor. May be in personal life he's very democratic. Holding elitist attitudes he earned through his hard labour. May not want to compromise it so far as his personal freedom is concerned. The point that worries all is: Does it display his arrogance? Or shows that he considers himself above the 'cattle class'! The blast, perhaps, is not for his habit of tweeting! It's the content that hurts Cong! "If he's happy to travel 'cattle class' in solidarity with the 'holy cows', what's wrong? It's just a smart-alec comment, many would like to believe! Poor Shashi Tharoor! Remember Clinton's haircut on Beverly Hills hitching a ride on Air Force One and Frenchman Sarkozy's craving for Rolex watches!
Tharoor is a well educated and renowned author and possibly his followers in tweets too. His tweets are educative. We often refer to the economy class as the 'cattle class' anyway? I can understand. About others? The simple idea is to communicate effectively, and Tharoor did it only beautifully. Glad that he didn't become UN Chief. Otherwise he would never have felt the pain of what millions of poor people are going through!
If anything, the whole austerity show of Cong is a 'sham'. How critical it is for the VVIP security apparatus to keep the movement of all those under its umbrella to be kept a secret. How good was it for the world to know at what time Rahul was travelling and on what train, from the security point of view? It was nothing but a conducted 'tamasha' in a way. Little wonder that photographers keep sprouting all over the route and inside the train while he travelled.
That Tharoor doesn't know India or Indians and never felt them with his heart is a different matter. He had been literally out of India for decades.. and India was never his concern even when he held important UN positions. Congress party, MP, the minister's post are all just stepping stones he required so that he can meet people on the world circuit eye-to-eye. Becoming a leading politician was his only hope after losing the SG post at UN. When he was the poster boy during elections, he portrayed himself as a gentleman politician. With power he shows his real face.... Not really to the people of 'his class'!
To us the millions of poor Indians such remarks are never going to bother about 'cattle class'. Take for example the suburban trains in Mumbai - aren't they worse than 'cattle class'? I am happy that, Tharoor went on to take a dig at 'holy cows' too, He accepts there are 'ordinary' and 'holy' cows in India! But this 'ongue-in-cheek'in some sense puts this austerity show in its context. We shouldn't let this austerity thing fool us into being satisfied that our so called leaders are experiencing a bit of what we do everyday. We want and demand real transparency, honesty, sincerity in deed - performance. Not this put-on austerity. Am I becoming serious?Atleast one politician had the guts and the wits to put the "austerity drive" of the Cong in real perspective!
If you don't say what comes to your mind in the first instance, in personal matters, you would in all probablity be lying. The more you think deeply, the further away you move from honestly expressing your views. The idea is that we are an english speaking country but haven't inherited any of the subtle humour that comes with the language. Only people who are educated and broad-minded having a higher level of appreciation of the English language can enjoy the 'tongue-in-cheek' comment.
Tharoor's comment can in no way change the system, unless the politicians adopt politics as a service for people than to accumulate more and more money and enjoy their life at the best availabe way on this earth. The theatre of the absurd is being staged for the benefit of the gullible morons of the "Andher Nagari". Enter the side-kick. The scripts go haywire. The side-kick doesn't follow the well written script!
Captain Gaiwaala on board
All 'holy cows' are requested
To fasten their noose belts;
To make your journey comfortable
Lovely meadows are visible on the screen;
Enjoy your flight, but don't look for haystack!
Cattle feeds and water will be served at
Lunch; buffaloes, bison and oxen
Are requested to behave themselves;
Sachets are kept behind the seats to
Safely secret milk for the concerned!
"Cattle class" reference to economy class has been around for few decades - not invented by Tharoor. Only he knows whether the 'all the holy cows' reference was simply a 'tongue-in-cheek' humor or a 'dig' at Sonia Gandy (no spelling mistake here) for the the Congress Party's austerity measures! Tharoor's tweet was more on a humorous note rather than to be taken seriously. Let's leave it there at that!
--
Subrahmanian SH
=====